2010 QJE  paper:
Title: Gaming Performance Fees by Portfolio Managers

Author Info

Dean P. Foster (Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.)
H. Peyton Young (University of Oxford and The Brookings Institution)

Abstract

We show that it is very difficult to devise performance-based compensation contracts that reward portfolio managers who generate excess returns while screening out managers who cannot generate such returns. Theoretical bounds are derived on the amount of fee manipulation that is possible under various performance contracts. We show that recent proposals to reform compensation practices, such as postponing bonuses and instituting clawback provisions, will not eliminate opportunities to game the system unless accompanied by transparency in managers' positions and strategies. Indeed, there exists no compensation mechanism that separates skilled from unskilled managers solely on the basis of their returns histories. (c) 2010 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology..