多关注些张五常的学术吧，少弄这些

道理是这样，但不要骂人

哈哈哈  这个是实情  很多地方都说过

[em43][em43]

职业水平和道德是两码事儿

得上搜狐

张五常的case跟林毅夫不一样。林被台湾当局通缉，属于政治犯。政治犯在某些人眼里是敌人，但在另一些人看来可能是英雄，比如，最近因为奥巴马访问古巴而被人忆起的切。格瓦拉，以及某些诺贝尔和平奖获得者。

张五常是完全的刑事犯，已经不是犯罪嫌疑人，而是被定罪的罪犯，是彻头彻尾的道德败坏者。他最近对中国经济的指手画脚，使人想起那些高喊反腐口号的贪官两面人。

就经济学学术水平而言，张五常是不咋地，他的论文、发言，除了吹嘘，就没有啥实质性内容了，的确符合江湖骗子的特征。

在一个国外教育是特有钱人特权的年代，留级吭吭哧哧读到博士也不证明智商特高或者特勤奋之类的，反正根本不需要工作赚钱，书就慢慢混着读。  加州伯克利博士资格考试没通过，只好去长堤大学拿到博士。

家里有钱，真有钱。

为富不仁也是真的。 95年告东周刊诽谤索赔250万美金成功，后来好像法律改了，只拿到一小部分赔款。

03年被美国ZF通缉，被媒体爆料，愣是一声不吭缩起来了，无可辩驳，只能发个越辩解越黑的网络辩白文章。

这种人的所谓经济理论，可信度和他的胡编辩解文章一样低。

南华早报的转帖：
How the case unfolded
PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 14 April, 2010, 12:00am
UPDATED : Wednesday, 14 April, 2010, 12:00am

January 28, 2003 Steven Cheung Ng-sheong and his wife indicted in Seattle on charges of tax evasion and conspiracy to defraud US government. Ordered to appear in court on February 20. Indictment alleges that the couple own 11 companies, including West Coast International and Celinal, but hid stakes in bid to avoid US taxes.
February 17 Cheungs issue statement saying they will not appear in court, believing they will not get fair trial.
February 20 US judge issues arrest warrants for them in Washington state. Couple reportedly flee to mainland from Hong Kong. The mainland, unlike Hong Kong, has no extradition treaty with the US.
February 25, 2004 Washington state files consumer fraud charges against Cheungs as owners of Thesaurus Fine Arts, a defunct Seattle store known to sell fake Asian antiquities.
October 28, 2005 The consumer fraud case reaches a settlement in which Thesaurus Fine Arts agrees to reimburse customers, and also to pay about US$350,000 in fines and attorneys' fees. The Cheungs' names are dropped from the suit as part of the settlement.
March 1, 2010 A defendant in a gallery theft trial testifies that Cheung owned three paintings alleged to have been stolen and gave them to the defendants as a reward for performing illegal tasks such as secretly importing paintings to the mainland. The gallery, Dandelion Fine Arts, is owned by West Coast International.
April 13 In his judgment, a Hong Kong judge affirms Cheung's ownership and control of Dandelion and West Coast International, the first time a Hong Kong authority has directly linked Cheung to details of the 2003 US indictment.

张五常这种人就是个骗子，跟郎咸平差不多，水平还没有郎咸平高。提出的都是些什么建议？？？！！！没有一个有可行性的，但是还是有很多人盲目相信，哎，可悲。

谢谢分享

名为搞经济学的江湖骗子！

第一次看到，真的很令人吃惊。

追查引用文献确实是一个好法子，对《佃农理论》追查的结果是：在《佃农理论》第七章表2中，1946-48年台湾佃耕地与自耕地的比值高达1.29，但按陈诚《台湾土地改革纪要》的数据计算，1948年的比值只有0.79；而根据汤惠荪《台湾之土地改革》，比值1.29应该是1939年的数据！关于1948年的土地数据，也可以查刘进庆《战后台湾经济分析》第100页，会更直接；由于汤惠荪《台湾之土地改革》不容易查到，可以间接查于宗先《两岸农地利用比较》第253页表9-2，尤其把该表与《佃农理论》第七章表2对比一下，是很有意思的事。

不过，张五常的文章逻辑性差是我一向对他的评价！
不过，天天吹嘘的佃农理论我倒还没去看看