如题，希望对大家有用：
1. The introduction gives a solid background and sets a good beginning to understand the whole paper

2. The problem is narrowly focused, precisely identified, and adequately understood

3. The relevant literature has been comprehensively and critically reviewed connecting all pieces of works together including recent publications

4. The problem has been logically and meaningfully deduced from the review of literature

5. The problem is important and significant from academic and/or policy points of view

6. The research methodology is current, sound, and sophisticated

7. The use of the methodology is appropriate and well justified

8. The mathematical/econometric model is theoretically sound and has some originality

9. The data used in the study are clean, appropriate, and updated

10. The findings are discussed and interpreted in detail

11. The arguments employed are logically consistent and/or empirically supported

12. The tables are simple, clear, understandable, and useful

13. The graphs, charts, and figures are meaningful and have enhanced the beauty and readability of the paper

14. The conclusion is complete with a clear set of policy recommendations

15. The policy recommendations are logically and consistently derived from empirical
findings and logical arguments

16. The focus of the paper is tight, sharp, and specific. It does not contain any loose or irrelevant materials

17. The paper is free form typographical, spelling, and grammatical errors and it consistently follows the American spelling style such as labor not labour, program not programme, center not centre, etc.

18. The paper is well structured, well organized, and well written

19. The reference list is complete, updated, and does not miss any seminal piece of work in the field