Environmental and Social Impact Analysis Stora Enso Plantation Project in Guangxi,China Final Report 5 February 2006
CONTENTS FOREWORD--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 Acknowledgements ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- i Executive Summary-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------iv 1.Background on the Partnership and ESIA----------------------------------------------------------------iv 2. An Outlook on the Industry in China and Guangxi----------------------------------------------------- v 3. Key Findings and Conclusions----------------------------------------------------------------------------vi 4. Recommendations for Stora Enso --------------------------------------------------------------------- xiii 5. Issues and Recommendations for Government Stakeholders--------------------------------------- xv 6. Content of Full Report ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- xvii Part I Background ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 Chapter 1. Background ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2 Part II Eucalypt Plantation Management--------------------------------------------------------------12 Chapter 2. Eucalypts and plantations--------------------------------------------------------------------- 13 Chapter 3. Eucalypts and Sustainability ----------------------------------------------------------------- 18 Chapter 4. Stora Enso’s Approach to Eucalypt Plantation Management in Guangxi, China ---- 24 Part III Environmental Impact Analysis ---------------------------------------------------------------32 Chapter 5. Environmental Methodology ----------------------------------------------------------------- 33 Chapter 6. Water Use and Impacts of Eucalypt Plantations ------------------------------------------- 35 Chapter 7. Soil Sustainability in Eucalypt Plantations -------------------------------------------------- 42 Chapter 8. Carbon Sequestration--------------------------------------------------------------------------- 49 Chapter 9. Biodiversity Assessment ----------------------------------------------------------------------- 51 Part IV Social Impact Analysis ------------------------------------------------------------------------67 Chapter 10. Social Analysis Methodology--------------------------------------------------------------- 68 Chapter 11. Affected Groups ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 71 Chapter 12. Land Rental ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 86 Chapter 13. Employment ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 104 Chapter 14. Special Populations and Other Special Topics ----------------------------------------- 122 Part V Integrated analysis of Social and Environmental Impacts ------------------------------- 146 Chapter 15. Methodology for Integrated Social-Environmental Analysis -------------------------- 147 Chapter 16. Cost-Benefit Analysis ----------------------------------------------------------------------- 148 Chapter 17. Social Analysis of Concerns about Envi. Impacts of Eucalypt Plantation----------- 151 Chapter 18. Natural and Cultural Heritage ------------------------------------------------------------ 154 Chapter 19. Scenario Analysis: What if the Stora Enso Project did not proceed? ---------------- 155 Chapter 20. Risks and Monitoring------------------------------------------------------------------------ 158 Part VI Conclusions, Recommendations and Suggestions--------------------------------------- 168 Theme: Technical Knowledge and Sustained Productivity ----------------------------------------- 170 Theme: Engagement with Society ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 171 Theme: Commitment to Stora Enso’s corporate principles ------------------------------------------- 173 References ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 176