夸克之一 发表于 2010-2-1 11:54
好吧，我本来是不想攻击fd和lz的。毕竟与人为善是一种美德。

ls有人把我想说的话给说穿了，lz认为fd的workshop就如何了得了，我虽然没有参加过美国牛校的workshop，但好歹每周也参加水平不错的workshop，来讲课的人都有点水平，而且我自己的判断绝对被国内所谓的牛人要强。真正的workshop是什么样子的？我不知道lz有没有见过作者被下面的听众批评到想找地洞。

我们系有一个宏观教授，非常年轻，他一直很犀利，批评作者比批评学生还狠。此人给Melitz改过稿子，Melitz在顶级期刊发表的文章中都要感谢他的批评校正。这是学术研讨，是风格，更是水平。我们平时看到和听到的都是那种毫无保留的、无情的批判。一个机构，一个团队，一个作者要想做出点成绩就要学会批评别人和被别人批评。

我给lz说个真实的故事，有一次UBC一个教授来做讲座，下面的听众不买账，照样骂人，照样批评。到最后，那个教授实在挂不住了，就拒绝回答提问，结果被群起而攻之，死得很惨。宏观微观计量，所有的教师都批判他，不仅如此，连给我们学生上课都不遗余力地批判他。lz啊，这是西方经济学研究为什么比中国强的很重要原因。因为人家是真正在讨论问题，在讨论的过程中没有什么面子权威和荣誉。

我可以很负责任地说，许多workshop最后是演讲者和听众拍桌子的，互相争执甚至到了水火不容的地步。请问FD的workshop到这个程度了么？

另外，我们还是见过AER作者的，我们系就有老师发表过AER，稍微次一点发过EER等。人家的学问水平，我自问，恐怕确实一辈子都赶不上了，但人家的精神和方法我还是可以学习的。

最要不得就是井底之蛙，夜郎自大。中国学术上不去，体制因素之外很关键一点就是：互相吹捧，一团和气。我对fd老师没有什么意见，最大的意见是见不得没有根据地造神。如果lz要谈问题，应该把某个论文拿出来，我们分析它好在哪里，不足在哪里，需要改进的地方是什么，如何改进，给大家留下了什么启示。这是做学问的样子。你谈哪个老师好，也要有点佐证吧？


附一点佐证，那个经常跟人拍桌子的宏观教授发表如下：

                                        Forthcoming

• The short-run dynamics of optimal growth models with delays, with O. Licandro and L. Puch, in Annales d'Economie et Statistiques.
• Flexible Prices and Business Cycles, with H. Dellas, in Journal of Money, Credit and Banking.
• Price resetting and inertia, with H. Dellas, in Journal of Macroeconomics.
• Monetary Misperceptions, Output and Inflation Dynamics, with H. Dellas, in Journal of Money, Credit and Banking.

2009

• Imperfect Information and the Business Cycle, with H. Dellas and F. Smets, in Journal of Monetary Economics, 56 (1), pp. S38-S56.

2008

• Modèles VAR ou DSGE: Que choisir?, with P. Fève, in Economie et Prévision, 127, pp. 155-174.
• Monetary Policy and Inflation in the 70s, with H. Dellas, in Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 40 (8), pp. 1765-1781.

2007

• The great inflation of the 1970s, with H. Dellas, in Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 39 (2), pp. 713-731.
• Technology Shocks and Employment, with H. Dellas, in Economic Journal, 117, pp. 1436-1459.

2006

• Predictability and Habit Persistence, with P. Fève and I. Ghattassi, in Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 30 (11), pp.  2217-2260.
• Globalization  Returns to Accumulation and the World Distribution of Output per Worker, with P. Beaudry, in Journal of Monetary Economics, 53 (5), pp.  879-909.
• A Note on Exact Solution of Asset Pricing ModelsHabit Persistence, with P. Fève and I. Ghattassi, in Macroeconomic Dynamics, 10 (2), pp.  273-283.
• Price Rigidity and the Selection of the Exchange Rate Regime, with H. Dellas, in Open Economies Review, 17 (1), pp.  5-26.

2005

• Decomposing the Twin Peaks: A Study of the Changing World Distribution of output per worker, with P. Beaudry and D. Green, in Review of Economics and Statistics, 87 (4), pp. 741-753.
• Electricity Consumption and ICT in the French Service Sector, with P. Fève and F. Portier, in Energy Economics, 27 (3), pp.  541-550.
• Poole in the New Keynesian Model, with H. Dellas, in European Economic Review, 49 (4), pp.  887-907.
• Demographics and Recent Productivity Performance: Insights from Cross-Country Comparisons, with P. Beaudry and D. Green, in Canadian Journal of Economics, 38 (2), pp.  309-344.
• Tax Distortions and the Case for Price Stability, with H. Dellas, in Journal of Monetary Economics, 52 (1), pp.  249-273.
• Habit Persistence,  Exogenous Money Growth Rule and Real Indeterminacy, with S. Auray and P. Fève, in Review of Economic Dynamics, 8 (1), pp.  48-67.

2004

• Supply Shocks and Employment in an Open Economy, with H. Dellas, in Economics Letters, 82 (2), pp.  231-237.

2003

• Recent Technological and Economic Change among Industrialized Countries: Insights from Population Growth, with P. Beaudry, in Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 105 (3).
• Monetary Union: A Welfare Based Approach, with M. Carré, in European Economic Review, 47 (3), pp.  521-552.

2002

• Asymmetriesin Monetary Policy Reaction Function: Evidence for U.S. French andGerman Central Banks, with F. Bec and M. Ben Salem, in Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics and Econometrics, 6 (2).
• Structural Inference and the Lucas Critique, with P. Fève and F. Langot, in Annales d'Economie et de Statistiques, 67 (2), pp.  183-206.
• Exchange rate systems and macroeconomic stability, with H. Dellas, in Journal of Monetary Economics, 49 (3), pp.  571-599.
• A small structural model for US aggregate job flows, with  P. Fève,  F. Langot and C. Perraudin, in Journal of Applied Econometrics, 17 (3), pp.  197-223.
• Habit Persistence and Beliefs Based Liquidity Effect, with S. Auray and P. Fève, in Economics Bulletin, 5 (2), pp.  1-7.
• Money and External Habit Persistence: A Tale for Chaos, with S. Auray et P. Fève, in Economics Letters, 76 (1), pp.  121-127.

2001

• Accuracy of Stochastic Perturbation Methods: The Case of Asset Pricing Models, with M. Juillard, in Journal of Economic Dynamics And Control, 25 (6), pp.  979-999.
• AHigher-Order Taylor Expansion Approach to Simulation of StochasticForward-Looking Modelsan Application to a Non-Linear Phillips Curve,with M. Juillard, in Computational Economics, 17 (2), pp.  125-139.

2000

• Stochastic Nominal Wages Contract in a Cash-in-Advance Model, with G. Ertz, in Louvain Economic Review, 66 (3).
• Job Protection and Labor Market Dynamics, with P. Fève,  F. Langot and C. Perraudin, in Revue d'Economie Politique, 110 (3), pp.  421-447.
• Gift exchange and the business cycle: the fair wage strikes back, with D. de la Croix, in Review of Economic Dynamics, 3 (1), pp.  166-193.
• Solving and estimating Dynamic Models under Rational Expectations, with P. Fève and C. Perraudin, in Computational Economics, 15 (3), pp.  201-221.