谨以此帖慰问门可罗雀的行为经济学版和黯然神伤的闲人斑竹!
论文名称 Essays in behavioral finance.
作者 Kumar, Alok.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 Cornell University.
日期 2003
指导老师 Masson, Robert
学科 Economics, Finance.
摘要 In this study, using data from a major discount brokerage house, I examine the effects of individual investors' correlated trading activities and their style-switching behavior on stock returns. I show that the buy-sell imbalance in individual investors' trades contains a systematic component that is uncorrelated with overall market movements. Using this common component as a measure of individual investor sentiment, I show that it is weakly correlated with standard risk factors and macro-economic variables, and is strongly influenced by “expert” advice from investment newsletters. This sentiment measure has incremental explanatory power for small-cap returns, particularly among stocks with lower prices, lower institutional ownership, and higher B/M ratios.;I also find that individual investors engage in style-based investing where they formulate their demands at a style-level (value versus growth, small versus large) and re-allocate funds between styles on the basis of past relative performance as well as “expert” advice from investment newsletters. Their style-switching behavior is unaffected by innovations in macro-economic variables or shifts in expectations about stocks' future cash-flows. However, I find that style-switching induced demand shifts generate co-movement in returns along style-based attributes. The contemporaneous relation between style returns and investors' demand shifts is strong, and I also find some evidence of return predictability using lagged demand shifts.
论文名称 Essays in behavioral corporate finance.
作者 Tate, Geoffrey Alan.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 Harvard University.
日期 2003
指导老师 Stein, Jeremy
学科 Economics, General.;Economics, Finance.;Business Administration, Management.
摘要 Overconfident managers overestimate their skill in selecting, implementing, and over-seeing projects. As a result, they overestimate the profitability of those projects to the shareholders. Further, this overvaluation causes a financing friction: overconfident CEOs believe their firm is undervalued by the capital market and, thus, are reluctant to raise external capital. So, even a manager who intends to act in the interests of the shareholders can make decisions that destroy shareholder value. We demonstrate the potential distortions of investment and takeover decisions that can arise due to managerial overconfidence.;We then test the overconfidence hypothesis in two ways. First, we use data on the personal portfolio decisions of a sample of CEOs in Forbes 500 companies. We classify CEOs as overconfident if they repeatedly fail to exercise options that are highly in the money, or if they habitually acquire stock of their own company. Second, we examine the manner in which the business press portrays these CEOs. We classify CEOs as overconfident if they are more often described as “confident” and “optimistic” than as “not confident,” “not optimistic,” “reliable,” “cautious,” “conservative,” “practical,” “frugal,” or “steady.” The two sets of measures are positively correlated. And, they all confirm the predictions of the overconfidence model. Overconfident CEOs are more likely to conduct mergers on average and this effect is due largely to diversifying (or negative expected value) mergers. Further, overconfidence has the largest effect in firms with the most cash and untapped debt capacity (or with minimal perceived financing costs). We also find that the market reacts negatively to takeover bids and that this effect is significantly stronger for overconfident managers. In the investment context, overconfident CEOs display significantly higher sensitivity of corporate investment to cash flow. And, here due to the maximization of perceived financing costs, this effect comes largely from CEOs in equity-dependent firms.
论文名称 Essays on market frictions.
作者 Wang, Tao.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 The Johns Hopkins University.
日期 2001
指导老师 Ball, Laurence
学科 Economics, General.;Economics, Finance.;Economics, Theory. 摘要 This dissertation concerns two areas that use the assumptions of near-rationality and market frictions. One area is the price-setting behavior of the firms studied by the New Keynesian economics. The other is the existence of “noise”, or irrational, traders and their roles in the financial markets studied by behavioral models.;In the second chapter, I examine whether a rise in import prices affects the price level more than a decline in import prices, and the reason why this might occur. From the simulation results derived in the modified Ball and Mankiw (1994) model, asymmetry is shown to be non-monotonic. Moreover, it depends on the size of trend inflation. Using a dynamic panel data set with 21 OECD countries, I then find that the effects of import price changes on domestic inflation are indeed asymmetric, contrary to what most of the literature finds. Further estimation indicates that the size of asymmetry depends on the size of trend inflation as well.;In the next chapter, simulated data from the Ball and Mankiw model (1994) are tested against the empirical evidence on the asymmetric effects of money shocks on output. It is found that the model explains 20% of the asymmetry. Furthermore, the model predicts that the effect of positive shocks on the output is statistically significant, while the data says it is near to zero. Therefore, the model overpredicts the effect of positive shocks and underpredicts, the effect of negative shocks.;In the fourth chapter, we conduct a simulation analysis of two naïve strategies to study the survival of small noise traders in futures trading and its contributing factors. The naïve strategies are buy-and-hold and sell-and-see. In “noise” traders models, speculators can survive and make positive profits because professional traders are unwilling to take the “noise trader risk” to bet against them. Assuming that volatility is one of the “trading spaces” created by noise traders, we can therefore test whether volatility helps speculators survive and earn higher returns.;The simulation results suggest that price volatility contributes positively to the survival rates and returns for the small noise traders. The results seem to be consistent with the notion that noise traders create their own space, supporting the argument that noise traders can survive. The results challenge the perception that volatility hurts small noise traders. We interpret this as evidence that volatility levels the playing field for small noise traders against smart money.
论文名称 Linking behavioral economics, axiomatic decision theory and general equilibrium theory.
作者 Wakai, Katsutoshi.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 Yale University.
日期 2002
指导老师 Morris, Stephen
学科 Economics, Theory.;Economics, Finance.
摘要 My dissertation links behavioral economics, axiomatic decision theory and general equilibrium theory to analyze issues in financial economics. I investigate two behavioral concepts: time-variability aversion, i.e., the aversion to volatility (fluctuation in payoffs over time) and uncertainty aversion, i.e., the aversion to uncertainty of state realizations. Chapter 1 develops a new intertemporal choice theory by endogenizing discount factors based on time-variability aversion, and shows that the new model can explain widely noted stylized facts in finance. The main contributions of this chapter are the findings that (1) time-variability aversion can be represented by time-varying discount factors based on very parsimonious axioms; (2) under the assumption of dynamic consistency, time-variability aversion implies gain/loss asymmetry in discount factors; (3) the gain/loss asymmetry boosts effective risk aversion over states by extreme dislike of losses while maintaining positive average time-discounting. This intertemporal substitution mechanism explains why the risk premium of equity needs to be very high relative to the risk-free rate.;Chapter 2 provides the conditions under which the no-trade theorem of Milgrom & Stokey (1982) holds for an economy of agents whose preferences follow uncertainty aversion as captured by the multiple prior model of Gilboa and Schmeidler (1989). First, I prove that given the agents' knowledge of the filtration, dynamic consistency and consequentialism imply that a set of ex-ante priors must satisfy the recursive structure. Next, I show that with perfect anticipation of ex-post knowledge, the no-trade theorem holds under the economy such that agents follow dynamically consistent multiple prior preferences.;Chapter 3 examines risk-sharing among agents who are uncertainty averse. The main objective is to provide conditions in the exchange economy such that agents' effective priors (and equilibrium consumptions) will be comonotonic and their marginal rates of substitution (weighted by these priors) will be equalized when agents have heterogeneous multiple prior sets. One set of sufficient conditions is for each agent's multiple prior set to be symmetric (or to be defined by a convex capacity) around the center of the simplex.
论文名称 Monetary policy in business cycle models with nominal rigidities.
作者 Kim, Jangryoul.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 Yale University.
日期 2003
指导老师 Sims, Christopher A.
学科 Economics, General.
摘要 This dissertation examines the implications of nominal rigidities for business cycle fluctuations and welfare improving monetary policy rules. The first chapter develops a dynamic monetary business cycle model that can generate persistent real effects of monetary disturbances. I demonstrate that an arbitrary degree of “contract multiplier” can be generated by a combination of nominal rigidities in labor and goods markets, where prices and wages are staggered in the spirit of Calvo (1983). Both the calibration exercises and analytical solutions suggest that wage stickiness is more effective than price stickiness in generating persistence. I also find that the oscillatory responses and lack of persistence in output in Chari et al. (2000) are due to a counterintuitive nuisance feature of deterministic staggered price contracts (i.e., the initial overshooting of prices reoptimized after monetary disturbances), and that stochastic staggering is free of such a nuisance feature and in principle able to generate persistence even if marginal cost is highly procyclical.;Putting the model through a formal reconciliation with U.S. data, the second chapter obtains the maximum likelihood estimates of the structural parameters of the model. The estimation results stand in favor of wage stickiness, in the sense that average duration of contracts is longer in labor market and that nominal wage rigidities are crucial for the model's performance in fitting actual U.S. data.;The third chapter examines the welfare implications of alternative monetary policy rules. The expected present discount utility of a representative household is used as the performance metric, and the welfare effects of the non-linear dynamics of the model are captured by the quadratic approximation method by Sims (2000). When the monetary authority aims at fixed paths of nominal variables, rules for fixed nominal income and money growth outperform fixed inflation rule. Variants of Taylor rules aiming at gradual adjusts of the implicit target variables outperform the two targeting rules. Long run deflationary rules increase welfare. The welfare maximizing rule among a class of simple Taylor-style rules is characterized by super-inertial adjustments in interest rate, strong short run anti-inflationary stance coupled with long run deflation, and increasing nominal interest rates (i.e., leaning against the wind) in response to higher real output in both growth rates and levels.
论文名称 Testing the behavioral life-cycle model: The effects of Social Security and pensions on personal saving.
作者 Sun, Wei.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 University of Notre Dame.
日期 2002
指导老师 Ghilarducci, Teresa
学科 Economics, General.;Economics, Labor.;Economics, Theory.
摘要 This study empirically investigates the behavioral life-cycle model (BLC) by framing the household's financial assets into liquid assets, less liquid assets, housing assets, and future wealth to test the hypothesis that the location of household wealth has effects on saving and consumption. The effects of Social Security and private pensions on personal savings are emphasized in the model through both cross-section and time-series analyses.;This paper uses 1983–1989 Survey of Consumer Finances and 1946–1992 Flow of Funds Accounts data sets. In the model with household net worth growth rate as a dependent variable to proxy household saving rate, the income and other financial assets do not have significant and discernable effects on net worth growth rate. In the model with household non-pension saving as a dependent variable, the results show that the saving behaviors of liquidity constrained households are more consistent with the BLC since social security wealth has a positive effect on non-pension savings while defined contribution plan has a negative effect. This suggests that the liquidity-constrained households, who are more likely to hit the spending income limit, are more likely to borrow against more liquid pension plan.;The aggregate analysis of the impact of social security wealth on consumption is more consistent with the BLC compared to the cross-section analysis since the results show that non-liquid assets, housing assets, and social security wealth do not increase personal consumption while disposable income and less liquid assets significantly increase personal consumption. This study does not confirm Feldstein's finding that the social security system reduces personal savings.;Gender analysis shows that the results of single male-headed households sample favor the BLC because they are more likely to consume out of current income and illiquid assets such as less liquid assets significantly increase their savings. Although the single female-headed households sample does not fully support the BLC, the future wealth in the model has significant and positive effects on net worth growth rates, implying that the social security and pension plans make single women save more.
论文名称 Three essays in behavioral finance, asset pricing and macroeconomics.
作者 Melamed, Nitzan.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 Brown University.
日期 2001
指导老师 Galor, Oded
学科 Economics, Finance.
摘要 This dissertation proposes a novel resolution for some outstanding puzzles in the financial literature. The first puzzle is the asset allocation puzzle. Conventional portfolio choice theory typically advises investors to shift their portfolio composition towards relatively safe assets as they age. Empirical evidence shows that the fraction of financial assets which individuals hold in stocks varies in a hump-shaped pattern over the life span. The second puzzle the limited stock market participation puzzle. Conventional portfolio choice theory predicts that most or all individuals should hold stocks, given the high historical equity premium. Contrary to this, 75 to 80 percent of United States households do not hold stocks directly. The third puzzle is referred to as the international diversification puzzle. Despite the obvious merits of diversification, we observe that most investors hold most of their portfolios domestically. I argue that resolutions to the three puzzles may lie in a model of optimal asset allocation over the life cycle of an individual with a prospect theory-based utility function. Prospect theory has been found to provide one of the few acceptable solutions to the equity premium puzzle and other behavioral anomalies. I find that prospect theory offers a solution to the asset allocation puzzle and the international diversification puzzle. In particular, the optimal share of the portfolio held in domestic stock under prospect theory follows a hump shaped pattern over the life span while no international investment is observed. Interestingly, prospect theory seems to resolve the stockholding puzzle as well. Unlike the conventional consumption-based approach, it predicts the existence of non-stockholders as well as stockholders, in accordance with observed behavior.;The dissertation also explores the interaction between business cycles and economic growth, two areas which have each generated voluminous literatures, but seldom have been analyzed in tandem. The modest number of studies that have tried to connect the two have mostly considered the effect of the variance embodied in business cycles on the economic growth trend. These papers generated varying results. This work departs from previous literature by proposing theoretically and indicating empirically a positive connection between serial correlation in business cycles and economic growth. When one accounts for serial correlation in business cycles, the contradictory findings of earlier studies regarding the effect of the variance in output on the growth rate of output can be reconciled.
论文名称 Three essays on arbitrage in expectations.
作者 Gatev, Evan.;
学位 Ph.D.
学校 Yale University.
日期 2001
指导老师 Goetzmann, William
学科 Economics, Finance.
摘要 The first essay tests a present value model in which investors revise daily their forecasts of the stochastic forward discount rates. Time-varying market risk premia are assumed to be proportional to conditional market volatilities. I test whether investors use forecasting heuristics similar to the ones proposed in recent behavioral models. The implied volatility from index options is used as a proxy for conditional short-term market volatility. I find that revisions in heuristic forecasts of volatility can explain up to 52% of the variance of contemporaneous excess returns and are consistent with an extrapolating heuristic. The second essay develops an equilibrium model of merger arbitrage where deal spreads are determined by the arbitrageurs who absorb supply shocks in the target stocks. The main prediction of the model is that deal spreads vary with merger activity depending on the elasticity of the arbitrage capital. I test the model's prediction and I find empirical evidence of a negative relationship between spreads and merger activity in the 1992–1998 period. The results support the conclusion that the supply of arbitrage capital is inelastic. The third essay tests a Wall Street investment strategy known as “pairs trading” with daily data over the period 1962–1997. Stocks are matched into pairs according to minimum distance in historical normalized price space. We test the profitability of several trading rules with six-month trading periods over the 1962–1997 period, and find average annualized excess returns of up to 12 percent for a number of self-financing portfolios of top pairs.
以下是引用闲人在2004-7-8 22:51:16的发言:典型的hold-up,俺为了全中国行为经济学爱好者的利益,认了。
现进贡黄金百两,布匹百匹,良驹10骑,美女一名
锦衣卫这么快就归顺恒山派了么,不能啊!一霎春气焰嚣张哦,师太得意张狂之时正是偶们奋起之日。
下面的贴子早期是单独发的,看起来不方便,所以合并在此处,共大家批评
国外大学行为经济学博士论文读后感 1、论文名称 Essays in behavioral finance.
作者 Kumar, Alok
好不容易读完一篇,这一篇的主题是讨论股价的共同变化问题,过去解释这现象主要通过单个股票的收益变化可能存在同方向,或者系统性冲击,比如宏观经济变量,如利率、石油价格冲击等。但史莱佛和希勒等人早期的研究发现,通过引入噪音交易者(也就是非理性交易者),能够更好的解释这种现象。
这篇论文的作者设计了一种计量方法,通过计算单个投资者在不同证券组合进行买卖的数量差异作为一种心态衡量指标,即the buy-sell imbalance(BSI),用这个剩余BSI和市场收益进行回归,发现噪音交易者的总体行为受到共同心态(即市场上的普遍看法)的影响,而且如果不考虑这种总体行为变化,单个噪音交易者行为不会影响市场价格波动。特别是发现了季节效应(但不包括周效应)
这也告诉我们,只要集体出现认知偏差,才能够说明一种经济现象是认知偏差带来的!
库马的研究进一步发现,单个投资者在买卖不同股票时,行为是相关联的。
按照Thaler的心理账户理论,投资者应该根据不同的股票特征进行相应的投资,两者之间不应该有关系,除非投资者不能区分股票间的差别。也就是说,投资者的心理账户只能在简单分类时才有用,在复杂分类下就不行了。这一点和哈耶克的感觉秩序理论和现代神经元经济学的研究似乎不一致。俺不懂。
库马进一步检验了投资者心态的决定因素,发现个人风险计算对心态影响很小;宏观经济变量影响中等;影响最大的是媒介显示的总体心态特征。
这说明媒体实际上左右者噪音交易者的行为。难怪俺们导师说现在记者最挣钱!
作者进一步检验了风格投资的影响。所谓风格投资就是按照某一种标准进行投资组合,比如大企业和小企业;科技股等等,组合内的股票之间比较关联。相对的就是马克维茨的分散投资组合,目的是风险最小化,通过降低风险创造价值。风格投资是通过收益最大化创造价值。
作者发现,投资者存在明显的风格投资,并且这种风格投资所包含的需求转换能够用于预测各自的价格变动趋势;风格投资对各种风险指标也有影响。
当然,这是显而易见的。因为如果投资者采取风格投资,那么必然导致市场上是各种风格资产组合,也就必然出现行为金融所预测的那样,出现规模效应等。有因就有果。难就难在如何才能找到证据证明风格投资的存在。库马的论文价值也就在此。
通观全文,注意两个关键:
1、在2.1.1中关于投资者心态的BSI测度,这是检验投资者心态是否存在以及是否影响股价变动的关键,如果没有这项指标的提出,整篇博士论文就失去价值,库马也就必不了业啦。
2、在3.2.1中关于风格水平的需求转换度量指标的设定,以及下一节的解释变量的选择。这是发现风格投资存在的关键所在。
至于计量方法上,也是通常的多元回归,后来用了蒙特卡罗模拟,俺不太了解。但这不重要,重要的是如何找到恰当的测度指标。
最后说一句:国外写论文是为了寻找证据,或者为了发现寻找证据的方法,反观国内的论文,都是空谈,只会浪费资源
楼主你太强了! Thank you!
But can you give us some essays about behavioral economics set on the analys of conceited person?
Thanks.