哪位大虾帮忙指点一下迷津?

这些问题看上去不光很业余，表达上也问题很多。很难想象专业交易公司会问这样的 Yes, No 事。

楼上误人不浅.这些问题决不业余,而是机构交易员必备常识.

1.
Trade long or short, but not both   Y
2.
Trade the same number of contracts in all markets  N
3.
If you have $100,000 to risk, you should risk $20,000-$30,000 on every trade  N
4.
If you have $100,000 to risk, you should risk less than $2,000 on every trade  Y
5.
If you have $15,000 to risk, you should risk $2,000-$3,000 on every trade   N
6.
When you enter a trade, you should know where to exit if a loss occurs  Y
7.
You can never go broke taking profits  Y
8.
The majority of traders are always wrong   Y
9.
Average profits should be about 3-4 times average losses  Y
10.
A trader should be willing to let profits turn into losses   Y
11.
A very high percentage of trades should be profits   N
12.
Needing and wanting money are good motivators to good trading  N
13.
One’s natural inclinations are good guides to decision making in trading
N
14.
Luck is an ingredient in successful trading over the short run   Y
15.
It’s good to follow hunches in trading  N
16.
Trends are not likely to persist  N
17.
It’s good to average down when buying  N
18.
A trader learns more from his losses than his profits  Y
19.
Luck is an ingredient in successful trading over the long run  N
20.
Other’s opinions of the markets are good to follow  N
21.
Buying dips and selling rallies is a good strategy  N
22.
It’s important to take a profit most of the time   N



本文来自: 人大经济论坛 详细出处参考：http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/viewth ... &from^^uid=720513

具体理由就不解释了,总之这些都是入场交易员必备的实战常识,
论坛理的人知道的可能不多.这方面的知识需要到技术分析论坛
去学习.推荐一本书《通往金融王国的自由之路》.

http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/redirect.php?tid=633783&goto=lastpost

这些题目如果是交易公司或者团体出的那么这个公司或者团体的操作风格应该是标准的趋势追踪。看看海龟培训班，trend following这些书里面讲得很明白。

个人感觉这些题目确实问得很肤浅，随便哪个正规点的业余交易论坛上可以找到一大堆。

好帖，学习了

解释一下这些选择：

1.
Trade long or short, but not both   Y  趋势追踪一般在一个市场中单方向下单，但是在好像可以在多个相关性不大的市场中作对冲操作。
2.
Trade the same number of contracts in all markets  N  趋势追踪有一个根据市场流动性Average ture range调解仓位的系统
3.
If you have $100,000 to risk, you should risk $20,000-$30,000 on every trade  N
4.
If you have $100,000 to risk, you should risk less than $2,000 on every trade  Y
5.
If you have $15,000 to risk, you should risk $2,000-$3,000 on every trade   N

这几题都是因为趋势追踪的圣经里面讲了一单要少于2%的资金，随着趋势的发展最大搞到3，4单就loaded了。

6.
When you enter a trade, you should know where to exit if a loss occurs  Y 趋势追踪系统里面的固定和移动止损。
7.
You can never go broke taking profits  Y     这里应该是N 不严格遵循机械系统给出的信号将无法做到用巨大的赢利来cover连续的较小的损失。
8.
The majority of traders are always wrong   Y 这个总是这么宣传的。。。。但机械系统的要求是不去想对错
9.
Average profits should be about 3-4 times average losses  Y 同样是趋势追踪法的特征。赢利巨大但是稀少，亏损多密但是数额小。
10.
A trader should be willing to let profits turn into losses   Y 严格遵循机械系统的信号指示。
11.
A very high percentage of trades should be profits   N 前面说了。趋势追踪的特征
12.
Needing and wanting money are good motivators to good trading  N 大错特错，都是这么宣传的
13.
One’s natural inclinations are good guides to decision making in trading
N 应该是严格遵循机械系统
14.
Luck is an ingredient in successful trading over the short run   Y 机械化趋势追踪追求小概率事件
15.
It’s good to follow hunches in trading  N 还是老问题
16.
Trends are not likely to persist  N 这个就是为什么我说是趋势追踪交易者出的题
17.
It’s good to average down when buying  N 趋势追踪不搞逆势补仓拉平价格
18.
A trader learns more from his losses than his profits  Y 这个大概都是这么宣传的。。。。
19.
Luck is an ingredient in successful trading over the long run  N 还是老话，机械化交易追求小概率事件，要build odd
20.
Other’s opinions of the markets are good to follow  N 更本就不考虑预测。
21.
Buying dips and selling rallies is a good strategy  N  趋势追踪是追涨杀跌。
22.
It’s important to take a profit most of the time   N 反了，大部分时候应该是学会承受损失，机械执行计划。


好多东西都没说，比如对信号准确与否的判定有没有认识，如何加仓实现超额赢利（其实是在trade off其作为一个整体的正确机会），如何进行资金管理（丹尼斯有说亏损百分之10后就把仓位减少20%）。不过显而易见是有关trend following的经典问题。

如果有这样的机构，也就是野鸡机构了。

好专业的内容啊，领教了，顶起！

新人刚来，进来看看，还不错，顶！

进来学习的，还不赖啊，呵呵！

野狐禅
insight 发表于 2010-3-26 20:27
这些问题决不业余,而是机构交易员必备常识.
如果有这样的机构，也就是野鸡机构了。
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
呵呵,火气不小吗?
做股票的机构可能并不太看重这些交易技术,因为大市值的股票
不多而且国内没有做空机制,但如果是参加外汇交易或者期货交易
的机构则是另一回事.

如果有这样的外汇期货交易机构，问出这样的问题，也就是野鸡机构了。