《中国金融学批判》是本人在2002年发表的一个帖子，在天涯论坛上可以看到2002年9月发表的 www.tianya.cn/publicforum/Content/develop/1/5870.shtml 。这个帖子取得了一定影响，还被《21世纪经济报道》所引用。当前已经是2010年，这个8年前的帖子还被转载和评论。
　　
　　当时这个帖子反应了大陆的现状，令人欣慰的是目前这个帖子已经不合适了。
　　
　　下面评论一下大陆的金融学水平。评价金融学水平的国际标准毫无疑问是看金融研究水平，金融研究水平意味着更聪明、更努力和更有知名度的师资。一个大学不靠师资还靠什么。前斯坦福商学院院长，诺贝而经济学奖得主斯本赛（Michael Spencer）就说过，一个商学院只需要两个事情就可以办好，招最好的教师和最好的学生。Chicago的教师花在教学上的时间还没有烂校多，不过它总是top。Fama在那里就是神一样的人物。
　　
　　一个学者，如果6，7年都没有像样的发表，只能证明在聪明程度和努力水平上有问题。另外，在媒体和政界出名的金融学家都是顶尖研究者，而不是上课高手。比如被OBAMA召为顾问的 前AFA会长Jeremy Stein (http://www.economics.harvard.edu/news/34 )
　　
　　如果不考虑不招本科和硕士的长江商学院，国内目前水平最高的金融学院是清华，最近两三年他们的全职教师中在世界前3的金融期刊上发表了好几篇文章，韩西有两篇JFE,杨之曙一篇JF, 朱英姿,王茵田各有一篇JFE。相比之下，光华只有一篇Jiang, Lee and Yue (Forthcoming, JFE)，还是会计系发的。我们暂时只考虑2007年以后的发表，徐信忠在几年前的那篇4人的JFE不在讨论范围。
　　
　　清华新进的陆瑶是密歇根大学毕业，导师KIM也不错。不过也有一些教师，待了很久都没有任何像样发表的，这种人老待着会影响其他人的积极性。
　　
　　之所以只考虑前3的杂志，因为国外像样的大学包括香港，新加坡的学校在评终身的时候只考虑前3，前4的杂志。而且这前3的杂志的水平相差不大。
　　
　　清华的进步当然与王江在清华的工作有紧密关系，他今年离开，去上海SAIF高等金融学院(www.saif.sjtu.edu.cn )当院长。同时带走了几乎所有的牛人特聘教授，所以，毫无疑问。SAIF或富得流油的长江将是中国的NO.1.虽然那里的很多教师都是兼职，不过阵容强大可以赶上世界50名的金融系。
　　
　　本连载1结束，最后附上一个世界金融研究前100名排名，是根据2005－2010年在前3杂志上的发表量。
　　
　　
　　The UTD Top 100 World Rankings of Business Schools Based on Research Contribution
　　(According to Top 3 Finance Journal Publication during 2005-2010 ) http://top100.utdallas.edu/

　　Rank University Articles Score Country
　　1 University of Chicago (Booth School of Business) 72 39.23 USA
　　2 New York University (Leonard N. Stern School of Business) 76 33.93 USA
　　3 Harvard University (Harvard Business School) 64 32.39 USA
　　4 University of Pennsylvania (The Wharton School) 58 27.14 USA
　　5 University of Michigan at Ann Arbor (Ross School of Business) 52 25.32 USA
　　6 Duke University (The Fuqua School of Business) 51 22.98 USA
　　7 University of California at Los Angeles (Anderson School of Management) 46 22.41 USA
　　8 University of Texas at Austin (McCombs School of Business) 48 20.86 USA
　　9 Columbia University (Graduate School of Business) 49 20.19 USA
　　10 University of California at Berkeley (Walter A. Haas School of Business) 38 18.37 USA
　　11 University of Maryland at College Park (Robert H. Smith School of Business) 33 17.74 USA
　　12 Ohio State University (Fisher College of Business) 43 17.44 USA
　　13 London Business School 45 17.19 United Kingdom
　　14 Stanford University (Graduate School of Business) 31 16.07 USA
　　15 INSEAD 26 16.03 FRANCE
　　16 University of Southern California (Marshall School of Business) 29 15.61 USA
　　17 Washington University at St. Louis (Olin School of Business) 31 14.57 USA
　　18 Boston College (Carroll School of Management) 31 14.21 USA
　　19 Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Sloan School of Management) 35 14.20 USA
　　20 Cornell University (Samuel Curtis Johnson Graduate School of Management) 33 13.89 USA
　　21 University of Washington at Seattle (Michael G. Foster School of Business) 23 12.24 USA
　　22 Hong Kong University of Science and Technology 25 12.15 China
　　23 Emory University (Goizueta Business School) 30 12.08 USA
　　24 Yale University (School of Management) 26 11.97 USA
　　25 Northwestern University (Kellogg School of Management) 28 11.82 USA
　　26 University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (Kenan-Flagler Business School) 27 11.74 USA
　　27 Indiana University at Bloomington (Kelley School of Business) 21 11.04 USA
　　28 University of Notre Dame (Mendoza College of Business) 16 10.99 USA
　　29 Dartmouth College (Tuck School of Business) 18 10.91 USA
　　30 University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (College of Business) 21 10.70 USA
　　31 University of Utah (David Eccles School of Business) 25 9.99 USA
　　32 Arizona State University (W.P. Carey School of Business) 21 8.78 USA
　　33 University of Wisconsin at Madison (Wisconsin School of Business) 15 8.49 USA
　　34 University of British Columbia (Sauder School of Business) 20 8.11 Canada
　　35 Vanderbilt University (Owen Graduate School of Management) 13 7.99 USA
　　36 Rice University (Jesse H. Jones Graduate School of Management) 16 7.53 USA
　　37 Pennsylvania State University at University Park (Smeal College of Business) 14 7.41 USA
　　37 Texas A&M University at College Station (Mays Business School) 18 7.41 USA
　　39 University of Toronto (Joseph L. Rotman School of Management) 17 7.25 Canada
　　40 CEPR 29 6.99 United Kingdom
　　41 Purdue University (Krannert Graduate School of Management) 16 6.91 USA
　　42 Tulane University (A. B. Freeman School of Business) 12 6.90 USA
　　43 McGill University (Desautels Faculty of Management) 15 6.86 Canada
　　44 University of Minnesota at Twin Cities (Carlson School of Management) 14 6.77 USA
　　45 City University of New York, Baruch College (Zicklin School of Business) 14 6.66 USA
　　46 University of Georgia (Terry College of Business) 15 6.26 USA
　　47 Michigan State University (The Eli Broad College of Business) 16 6.21 USA
　　48 University of California at Irvine (Paul Merage School of Business) 12 5.91 USA
　　49 University of Arizona (Eller College of Management) 15 5.70 USA
　　50 University of Rochester (William E. Simon Graduate School of Business) 12 5.61 USA
　　51 HEC France 15 5.58 France
　　52 Singapore Management University (Lee Kong Chian School of Business) 14 5.57 Singapore
　　53 University of Florida (Warrington College of Business) 10 5.49 USA
　　54 University of Iowa (Henry B. Tippie College of Business) 9 5.45 USA
　　55 University of Texas at Dallas (School of Management) 13 5.39 USA
　　56 Rutgers University at New Brunswick and Newark (Rutgers Business School) 14 5.10 USA
　　57 Tilburg University (Faculty of Economics and Business Administration) 16 5.04 The Netherlands
　　58 University of Lausanne ( Faculty of Business & Economics) 13 4.93 Switzerland
　　59 Carnegie Mellon University (Tepper School of Business) 7 4.83 USA
　　60 Case Western Reserve University (Weatherhead School of Management) 9 4.29 USA
　　61 Brigham Young University (Marriott School of Management) 7 4.28 USA
　　62 Oxford University (Said Business School) 14 4.15 United Kingdom
　　63 University of Colorado at Boulder (Leeds School of Business) 9 4.14 USA
　　64 University of South Carolina at Columbia (Moore School of Business) 10 4.08 USA
　　65 Southern Methodist University (Edwin L. Cox School of Business) 12 4.01 USA
　　66 University of Delaware (Alfred Lerner College of Business and Economics) 7 3.86 USA
　　66 University of Houston (C.T. Bauer College of Business) 9 3.86 USA
　　66 University of Missouri at Columbia (Robert J. Trulaske, Sr. College of Business) 9 3.86 USA
　　69 National University of Singapore (Business School) 10 3.65 Singapore
　　70 University of California at Davis (Graduate School of Management) 8 3.61 USA
　　71 Nanyang Technological University (Nanyang Business School) 7 3.58 Singapore
　　72 University of Virginia, McIntire (McIntire School of Commerce) 10 3.49 USA
　　73 University of Alberta (School of Business) 7 3.48 Canada
　　74 University of Virginia, Darden (Darden Graduate School of Business Administration) 9 3.44 USA
　　75 George Mason University (School of Management) 8 3.33 USA
　　76 Drexel University (Bennett S. LeBow College of Business) 9 3.30 USA
　　77 Georgia State University (J. Mack Robinson School of Business) 8 3.20 USA
　　77 York University (Schulich School of Business) 7 3.20 Canada
　　79 Norwegian School of Management ( ) 7 3.19 Norway
　　79 Boston University (School of Management) 9 3.19 USA
　　81 University of Miami (School of Business Administration) 6 3.16 USA
　　81 University of Connecticut (School of Business) 4 3.16 USA
　　81 Universitat Pompeu Fabra ( ) 4 3.16 Spain
　　84 Georgia Institute of Technology (College of Management) 8 3.14 USA
　　85 University of Amsterdam ( ) 8 3.11 The Netherlands
　　86 Georgetown University (The McDonough School of Business) 8 2.98 USA
　　87 University of California at San Diego (School of Management) 7 2.74 USA
　　87 University of Oregon (Charles H. Lundquist College of Business) 7 2.74 USA
　　89 American University (Kogod School of Business) 6 2.66 USA
　　89 Bentley College ( ) 5 2.66 USA
　　89 Federal Reserve Bank of New York ( ) 5 2.66 USA
　　92 City University of Hong Kong (Faculty of Business) 8 2.61 China
　　93 University of Manchester ( ) 6 2.58 United Kingdom
　　94 Hebrew University of Jerusalem ( ) 7 2.49 Israel
　　95 Copenhagen Business School 4 2.45 Denmark
　　95 University of Kansas (College of Business) 6 2.45 USA
　　97 University of Western Ontario (Richard Ivey School of Business) 3 2.33 Canada
　　97 Lancaster University ( ) 6 2.33 United Kingdom
　　99 Louisiana State University at Baton Rouge (E.J. Ourso College of Business Administration) 8 2.24 USA
　　99 Texas Tech University (Rawls College of Business) 4 2.24 USA
　　99 Imperial College ( ) 7 2.24 United Kingdom